Hello fellow generals.
In a couple of weeks, I'll be attending a tournament. This is my list, and I would be very pleased to hear some thoughts and ideas from you. The idea behind the list is that it should be mobile, shooty and still be able to claim objectives. My experience so far with HBE in 9th tells me that our blocks can't go head to head with other big blocks, thus I try to avoid them or weaken them first.
Prince Master of Canreig Tower: Book of Meladys; Shard of cenyrn; Mithril Mail; Lucky charm; Great weapon 390
Commander BSB Master of Canreig Tower: Fire, Shadow, Halberd, Dispel scroll 213
6 Highborn Lancers: Mounts protection, Standard Bearer 142
5 Highborn Lancers: Mounts protection, Standard Bearer 120
5 Elein Reavers 85
27 Citizen Spears: Heavy armour, full command 297
10 Lion guard: Skirmish, Champion, Standard Bearer (banner of becalming) 205
19 swordmasters: full command, Rending banner 303
Lion chariot 100
Lion chariot 100
Sea guard reaper multi shot 80
Sea guard reaper multi shot 80
Sea guard reaper multi shot 80
9 Greay watchers: long bows 144
Flamespyre phoenix 160
List for an upcoming ETC tournament
- JimmyGrill
- Posts: 25
- Joined: Sun Oct 06, 2013 6:43 pm
- Location: Munich, Germany
Re: List for an upcoming ETC tournament
Well, reminds me a lot of my army, so I like the basic concept, I guess
One thing though, you can't have two MoCT, as they are one of a kind
Another thing that seems to be lacking is chaff/diverters, you only have a single Reaver unit for that... I have found diverters to be critical for an army concept like this because you will almost always need combo-charges to prevail.
I'm not a big fan of your choice of magic banners, I don't think SM have a huge need for AP, I think there are much better choices for them. Personally, I run mine with Stalker Standard, but there are several other attractive options, too. I often go for the movement banners, because the movement phase is where the game is decided, and HBE need to make maximum use of their speed advantage to win.
Concerning HA for the spears, this is also a contentious point... I have tried both, and while I like the extra pip of AS, I have found the spears' numbers is their best protection, and also for the price of the HA upgrade I get an eagle, so that settled it. If it were cheaper (like 1.5 points), I will go for HA again.
YMMV, though.
One thing though, you can't have two MoCT, as they are one of a kind
Another thing that seems to be lacking is chaff/diverters, you only have a single Reaver unit for that... I have found diverters to be critical for an army concept like this because you will almost always need combo-charges to prevail.
I'm not a big fan of your choice of magic banners, I don't think SM have a huge need for AP, I think there are much better choices for them. Personally, I run mine with Stalker Standard, but there are several other attractive options, too. I often go for the movement banners, because the movement phase is where the game is decided, and HBE need to make maximum use of their speed advantage to win.
Concerning HA for the spears, this is also a contentious point... I have tried both, and while I like the extra pip of AS, I have found the spears' numbers is their best protection, and also for the price of the HA upgrade I get an eagle, so that settled it. If it were cheaper (like 1.5 points), I will go for HA again.
YMMV, though.
Re: List for an upcoming ETC tournament
Hi JimmyGrill
Thanks for the response. You are of course right about the MoCT and one of kind, so I've tried a new list:
Archmage lvl. 4 Death Asfad Scholar; Obsidian Nullstone; Book of meladys 345
Commander BSB Master of Canreig Tower: Shadow, Fire, Halberd 213
6 Highborn lancers: Standard Bearer (gleaming Icon) 152
5 Highborn Lancers standard bearer 125
5 Elain reavers: Bows 90
27 Citizen spears Heavy armour full command 297
10 Lion guard: Skirmish, Banner of discipline; Champion 195
19 Swordmasters full command (flaming standard) 288
Lion chariot 100
Lion chariot 100
Sea guard Reaper 80
Sea guard Reaper 80
Sea guard Reaper 80
9 Grey watchers 144
Flamespyre 160
Giant eagle 50
I'm not really sure about a lvl. 4 in a HBE army, but I just think death with extra range has some potential. There should also be some synergy with the path attribute, the amount of shooting the list contains and a terror causing monster.
I've also added a eagle, which hopefully buys be a extra round of shooting/magic. I will be testing the list over the next weeks, so we will have to see how it works out
Thanks for the response. You are of course right about the MoCT and one of kind, so I've tried a new list:
Archmage lvl. 4 Death Asfad Scholar; Obsidian Nullstone; Book of meladys 345
Commander BSB Master of Canreig Tower: Shadow, Fire, Halberd 213
6 Highborn lancers: Standard Bearer (gleaming Icon) 152
5 Highborn Lancers standard bearer 125
5 Elain reavers: Bows 90
27 Citizen spears Heavy armour full command 297
10 Lion guard: Skirmish, Banner of discipline; Champion 195
19 Swordmasters full command (flaming standard) 288
Lion chariot 100
Lion chariot 100
Sea guard Reaper 80
Sea guard Reaper 80
Sea guard Reaper 80
9 Grey watchers 144
Flamespyre 160
Giant eagle 50
I'm not really sure about a lvl. 4 in a HBE army, but I just think death with extra range has some potential. There should also be some synergy with the path attribute, the amount of shooting the list contains and a terror causing monster.
I've also added a eagle, which hopefully buys be a extra round of shooting/magic. I will be testing the list over the next weeks, so we will have to see how it works out
Re: List for an upcoming ETC tournament
Isn't it risky to equip your BSP without any armor/ward saves?
-
- Green Istari
- Posts: 13847
- Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2008 11:26 am
- Location: Otherworld
Re: List for an upcoming ETC tournament
This looks like a good point to me. The list has speed but not on really heavy hitters. The shooting is enough to be useful here but not enough to be able to sit back vs shooty opposition.JimmyGrill wrote:I often go for the movement banners, because the movement phase is where the game is decided, and HBE need to make maximum use of their speed advantage to win.
A New Blog (Orcs and Goblins)
http://ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=70550
Cavalry Prince Reloaded
http://ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=80&t=70001
http://ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=70550
Cavalry Prince Reloaded
http://ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=80&t=70001
Re: List for an upcoming ETC tournament
So I attended the tournament which was Called ETC warmup. We played in teams like ETC and many of the top countries where present (Germany, England, Sweden).
Anyway to make a long story short the list was quit succesfull. I won 4, 1 draw and 1 loss.
Things I really liked:
Lvl. 4 death with Asfad honour: Oh he was good. He just murders monsters, which are out of the ld range from the general. Further, he is a constant threat for opponents generals with his soul leach LD10. The path has relatively low casting values and works great with shooting.
Lion chariot: They are just great. An unfortunate thing is that IMO they are better in every way than the knights of Rymam which is 60 points more. Of course the knights can take a banner, but otherwise I prefer the lion chariot.
Spears: They are great as well. If I could change a thing I would skip HA on them and also give them the gleaming icon. Usually I send them outside general and BSB range because I need them to perform specific tasks only they can do due to their lethal strike. Best example is to take on a steam tank. They just murder it over 2-3 rounds of combat.
The only thing, I'm not fully convinced by is the flamespyre. It did well, but it is just so extremely fragile with only 5 wounds and t5. I included it because a fear/terror causing creature is very good with death magic. However, you don't really want the flamespyre in close combat..
Otherwise I really like the feel of the list in the sense that it is very mobile, shooty and have good magic. Finally it can also do some damage in close combat, but you need to whittle your opponent down before combat happens - Feels elvish .
Anyway to make a long story short the list was quit succesfull. I won 4, 1 draw and 1 loss.
Things I really liked:
Lvl. 4 death with Asfad honour: Oh he was good. He just murders monsters, which are out of the ld range from the general. Further, he is a constant threat for opponents generals with his soul leach LD10. The path has relatively low casting values and works great with shooting.
Lion chariot: They are just great. An unfortunate thing is that IMO they are better in every way than the knights of Rymam which is 60 points more. Of course the knights can take a banner, but otherwise I prefer the lion chariot.
Spears: They are great as well. If I could change a thing I would skip HA on them and also give them the gleaming icon. Usually I send them outside general and BSB range because I need them to perform specific tasks only they can do due to their lethal strike. Best example is to take on a steam tank. They just murder it over 2-3 rounds of combat.
The only thing, I'm not fully convinced by is the flamespyre. It did well, but it is just so extremely fragile with only 5 wounds and t5. I included it because a fear/terror causing creature is very good with death magic. However, you don't really want the flamespyre in close combat..
Otherwise I really like the feel of the list in the sense that it is very mobile, shooty and have good magic. Finally it can also do some damage in close combat, but you need to whittle your opponent down before combat happens - Feels elvish .
-
- Green Istari
- Posts: 13847
- Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2008 11:26 am
- Location: Otherworld
Re: List for an upcoming ETC tournament
Thanks for the update Andros, that's a strong event and a good result.
So would you say Death magic is as fearsome as in 8th? Maybe the Lion Chariots work well here because you have plenty of Infantry? I'm thinking Knights might be better in a list with fast heavy threats because they can March? The Gleaming Icon was often a good choice for Spears in early 8th.
So would you say Death magic is as fearsome as in 8th? Maybe the Lion Chariots work well here because you have plenty of Infantry? I'm thinking Knights might be better in a list with fast heavy threats because they can March? The Gleaming Icon was often a good choice for Spears in early 8th.
A New Blog (Orcs and Goblins)
http://ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=70550
Cavalry Prince Reloaded
http://ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=80&t=70001
http://ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=70550
Cavalry Prince Reloaded
http://ulthuan.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=80&t=70001
-
- Posts: 705
- Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2011 7:26 pm
- Location: Portland, Oregon, USA
Re: List for an upcoming ETC tournament
How'd you get Ld10?AndrosV wrote:Things I really liked:
Lvl. 4 death with Asfad honour: Oh he was good. He just murders monsters, which are out of the ld range from the general. Further, he is a constant threat for opponents generals with his soul leach LD10. The path has relatively low casting values and works great with shooting.
thelordcal wrote:Or he uses his big a$$ banner pole as a great weapon...
wisetiger7 wrote:That's what she said.
Asurion Whitestar wrote:I would normally delete such an off topic post, but this is just too good. Classic..!!